When customers are deciding which local business to trust, they rarely take a company’s word for it alone. Customer reviews provide an outside perspective that can turn an unfamiliar business into a much more comfortable choice.
Need to Know
- Reviews build trust. They offer potential customers evidence that real people have done business with you and can speak to their experiences.
- Quantity and quality. A strong overall rating is helpful, but a healthy number of consistent, recent reviews adds credibility.
- Reviews influence local visibility. They’re an important part of a business’s online presence and local search performance.
- Asking works. BrightLocal’s 2026 survey found that 83% of consumers who were asked to leave a review went on to do so.
- Make it routine. A simple process involving timely emails or texts and an occasional follow-up can help generate reviews consistently.
Why Are Customer Reviews So Important?
Imagine you’ve just moved and you need to find a plumber in a city you’re unfamiliar with. You find two businesses that appear equally qualified. One has a polished website and promises excellent service, but only three online reviews. The other has a similar website, but 100 customers have shared positive experiences.
Which one feels like the safer choice?
Most people would lean toward the second business. Not necessarily because it’s guaranteed to be better, but because there’s more evidence to support its claims.
That’s the psychology behind social proof: when we’re uncertain about a decision, we often look to the experiences of others for reassurance. Reviews help establish several important trust signals:
- Reputation: They show how previous customers perceive the business, its service quality, and professionalism.
- Confidence: They reduce the perceived risk of choosing an unfamiliar provider.
- Consistency: Similar feedback across multiple customers suggests that good experiences aren’t isolated incidents.
- Accountability: A business that responds thoughtfully to feedback demonstrates that it cares about its customers after the sale.
This is especially important for small local businesses. Unlike large national brands, smaller companies may not have widespread name recognition or years of brand exposure to lean on. Reviews help bridge that gap by letting satisfied customers do some of the talking.
And consumers are listening. BrightLocal’s 2026 Local Consumer Review survey found that 97% of consumers read online reviews for local businesses, while 85% said positive reviews make them more likely to use a business.
How Many Reviews Do You Need, and What Rating Should You Aim For?
There isn’t a universal magic number, but the quantity of reviews can influence how credible a business appears.
Think about it this way: if a business has 5 five-star reviews, that’s encouraging, but it’s a relatively small sample. For all you know, the business’ own employees may be the ones that left them. Meanwhile, if another has 150 reviews averaging 4.8 stars, there’s considerably more customer feedback supporting its reputation.
BrightLocal’s 2026 survey found that 47% of consumers wouldn’t use a business with fewer than 20 reviews. Only 9% were willing to consider businesses with five or fewer. Pair that with Northwestern University‘s findings that a product with five reviews had a 270% greater purchase likelihood than a product with no reviews, and their importance becomes incredibly obvious.
Star ratings matter, too. The same survey found that 92% of consumers consider ratings when choosing a business, and 68% said they would only use businesses with at least four stars. Nearly one-third (31%) required 4.5 stars or higher.
That doesn’t mean every business needs hundreds of reviews or a perfect, sparkling five-star rating. But a realistic goal would be to build a substantial collection of positive, authentic feedback while maintaining a strong average rating. Say, 50 reviews with a 4.6+ average. If you get just one good review a week, you’ll hit that goal within a year.
Another note: don’t overlook recency, either. A business with 100 reviews but none from the past two years may leave customers wondering whether its service is still as good as it once was. In fact, 74% of consumers in BrightLocal’s 2026 survey said they look for reviews written within the last three months.
The main takeaway? Build your review count steadily, maintain a strong rating, and keep fresh feedback coming in.
How Can You Get More Customer Reviews?
The good news is that getting reviews doesn’t have to be complicated. In fact, the most effective starting point is often the simplest: just ask.
BrightLocal’s 2026 survey found that 83% of consumers who were asked to leave a review went on to do so. Yet many businesses still leave review collection to chance, hoping customers will take the initiative themselves.
Here’s a straightforward process most businesses can follow:
- Choose your review platform. For many local businesses, Google Business Profile is a sensible starting point. You may also want to build a presence on platforms like Yelp, Facebook, or more industry-specific platforms.
- Create a direct review link. Make it easy for customers to leave feedback without having to search for your business themselves. Google lets businesses create a review link or QR code.
- Ask at the right time. For most businesses, sending a request around one day to one week after the job is completed is a reasonable timeframe.
- Send a friendly email or text. Thank the customer for their business, briefly explain that feedback is appreciated, and include your review link. Keep the request simple and straightforward.
- Follow up once. Even with the best of intentions, people can easily forget. If a customer hasn’t responded, send one polite reminder several days later, but avoid repeatedly contacting them if they still don’t reply.
- Respond to the reviews you receive. Thank customers for feedback (both positive and negative) and address concerns professionally. Your responses are visible to future customers, too.
Email is particularly worth considering: BrightLocal’s 2025 survey found that 40% of consumers were most likely to leave a review when asked by email, compared with 27% who preferred being asked in person. For trades and service businesses, the survey found that customers generally expected requests within three days to one week.
Best Practices to Get More Reviews
A consistent process is important, but how you ask matters, too.
- Keep it genuine. Thank customers for their business and invite honest feedback. Don’t tell them what to say or pressure them to leave a particular rating.
- Make it easy. Give customers something that leads them where they need to go (a link, QR code, etc.). Don’t expect them to figure out how to leave a review.
- Ask everyone. Don’t selectively request reviews only from customers you expect to be happy. You want an honest picture of the customer experience.
- Never buy or incentivize reviews. Google and other popular directories prohibit offering discounts, free products, or other rewards in exchange for reviews.
- Don’t ignore negative feedback. A thoughtful response can demonstrate accountability and give you an opportunity to address a problem.
Build a Stronger Online Presence for Your Business
Customer reviews are an important piece of the local marketing puzzle. They help establish credibility, reassure prospective customers, and reinforce the reputation you’re working hard to build. They’re also one of several signals that contribute to a business’s local search presence.
At JLFisher Marketing, we believe successful digital marketing starts with understanding how customers actually find, evaluate, and choose businesses. From local SEO and Google Business Profile optimization to strategic website content, we help small businesses strengthen their online presence and compete more effectively in their markets.
Want to help more local customers find your business? Explore our SEO and Content Marketing services to see how a thoughtful approach to search engine visibility can help turn more online searches into real revenue opportunities.





